Lawyer Pavel PetrovLawyer Pavel Petrov

RURU ENEN

Contractual Penalties in Russian Bankruptcy: Calculation and Priority

Short answerA contractual penalty forms part of a monetary claim but is recorded separately from principal and interest. Third-priority penalties are paid only after principal and applicable interest. The creditor must prove the contractual or statutory basis, calculation period and amount at the relevant bankruptcy cut-off date.
01

Prove the basis

The agreement or statute must identify the breach, rate and any cap.

02

The period is limited

Bankruptcy imposes special cut-off rules for sanctions on register claims.

03

Separate register entry

The penalty does not increase voting principal and follows special payment priority.

Calculation review

ElementCreditor evidenceCommon error
BasisContract clause or statutePenalty claimed for an uncovered breach
Base amountOverdue obligationCharging on paid debt
PeriodDefault start and lawful cut-offContinuing beyond the bankruptcy restriction
RateDaily or other rate and capMixing penalty, interest and damages

Article 137(3) requires penalties and financial sanctions to be recorded separately and paid after principal and interest. Current obligations require a different analysis based on when the debt and breach arose.

Distinguish three charges: contractual penalties, monetary interest and moratorium interest have different legal bases, periods and priorities.

Creditor workflow

Establish principal

Reconcile the contract, acts, deliveries, payments and default date.

Calculate by period

Show rate changes, partial payments and the applicable bankruptcy cut-off.

Separate components

List principal, contractual interest, penalty and other sanctions separately.

File the evidence

Attach a transparent table, primary documents and service evidence.

Reduction

A debtor or participant may invoke Civil Code Article 333 where the penalty is manifestly disproportionate. Bankruptcy alone does not produce an automatic reduction; evidence and a reasoned calculation are required.

Documents

  • agreement and amendments;
  • acts, invoices, deliveries and payments;
  • demand and breach notices;
  • period-by-period calculation;
  • EFRSB publications and bankruptcy orders;
  • partial-payment evidence.

FAQ

Is the penalty included with principal?

It is established in the same case but recorded and paid separately.

Does it run until judgment?

Not necessarily; a bankruptcy cut-off may apply earlier.

Can it be filed after principal?

That depends on the stage, register deadline and previous claim determination.

Is it discharged in personal bankruptcy?

It generally follows the underlying obligation subject to Article 213.28 exceptions.

Official sources

Related guides: moratorium interest, Article 395 interest and creditor-register filing.

Need to review a calculation and claim priority?

Initial consultation