Civil Code conditions
Claims must be mutual, homogeneous and mature for set-off.
Priority prevails
Set-off must not provide individual recovery outside the collective process.
Pre-filing risk
A set-off made before the petition can still be reviewed as a preference.
Four-level review
| Level | Required finding | Warning sign |
|---|---|---|
| Mutuality | Each party is debtor and creditor of the other | A claim belongs to a third party |
| Homogeneity | The result mirrors mutual performance | Money is matched against delivery of an asset |
| Maturity | The active claim is due or lawfully accelerated | Declaration predates Civil Code conditions |
| Bankruptcy | Register and current-payment priority remain intact | One creditor receives more than in the process |
Civil Code Article 410 permits unilateral set-off, but Bankruptcy Law protects collective and proportionate creditor recovery. A set-off valid outside insolvency may therefore be restricted or avoided in bankruptcy.
Workflow
Build the timeline
Map contracts, performance, defaults, the declaration, petition acceptance and procedure dates.
Classify both claims
Separate register and current claims, principal, interest and sanctions.
Compare with priority
Measure actual recovery against the statutory distribution outcome.
Review avoidance periods
Assess preference indicators, knowledge and ordinary-course evidence.
Documents
- contracts creating both claims;
- acts, deliveries, reconciliations and payments;
- set-off declaration or agreement and delivery proof;
- claim calculations at the set-off date;
- EFRSB notices and bankruptcy orders;
- creditor and payment-priority evidence.
FAQ
Can claims be set off during observation?
Only where special bankruptcy restrictions and creditor priority are not breached.
Is a reconciliation act enough?
Usually no; it does not replace a clearly delivered set-off declaration or agreement.
Can current claims be set off?
Current-payment priority and the actual effect must be reviewed separately.
What follows avoidance?
Both obligations are restored subject to Bankruptcy Law Article 61.6.
Official sources
- Civil Code Article 410
- Supreme Court Plenum Resolution No. 6
- Bankruptcy Law
- Supreme Commercial Court Plenum Resolution No. 63
Related guides: creditor-register filing, current claims and transaction restitution.
Need to assess set-off validity and avoidance risk?
Initial consultation