Clear replacement
The agreement must show that the old obligation ends and only the new one remains.
Ancillary rights change
Security and sanctions generally end unless preserved by agreement or law.
Substance prevails
A new document does not guarantee a new debt date or safer priority.
Novation or another arrangement
| Structure | Effect | Key indicator |
|---|---|---|
| Novation | Old obligation is replaced | New subject or basis and clear termination intent |
| Amendment | The same obligation continues | Only term, amount or performance order changes |
| Accord and satisfaction | Obligation ends upon alternative performance | Termination depends on actual transfer |
| Debt acknowledgment | Existing debt is confirmed | No new subject or basis |
Civil Code Article 414 requires an agreement replacing the obligation. Supreme Court Plenum Resolution No. 6 explains that changing amount or timing alone is insufficient. Where novation and accord are disputed, the agreement’s substance and termination moment control.
Review workflow
Reconstruct the original debt
Prove the contract, performance, amount and original accrual date.
Read the replacement agreement
Identify clear termination intent, the new subject or basis and effective conditions.
Review security
Determine whether pledge, suretyship, penalties and other ancillary rights were preserved.
Measure bankruptcy impact
Compare amount, maturity, priority and security before and after the transaction.
📝 Reviewing a novation agreement
Checked on 25 October 2026: Civil Code Article 414, Supreme Court Plenum No. 6 paragraph 22 and Supreme Commercial Court Plenum No. 63 paragraph 13.
For a creditor, comparing the two obligations matters more than the heading “novation”. Prepare a before-and-after file with the original debt records. If the counterparty merely proposes a new schedule, establish whether the parties actually terminate and replace the obligation or amend its performance terms.
| Agreement item | Establish | Cross-check |
|---|---|---|
| Original obligation | Basis, parties, origination date and unpaid amount | Contract, delivery/payment and reconciliation |
| New obligation | New subject or basis, amount and performance terms | Agreement and schedules |
| Replacement intent | When the original ends and what the creditor may demand afterwards | Effective conditions and correspondence |
| Ancillary rights | Interest, penalties, security and affected persons | Itemised calculation, security agreements and required consents |
| Bankruptcy treatment | Original origination date and bankruptcy-petition acceptance date | Underlying records and court order |
A later agreement does not convert an old registered claim into a current claim
Paragraph 13 of Plenum No. 63 expressly requires the original obligation’s origination date when classifying the new monetary obligation under Insolvency Law Article 5. A registered claim does not become current through later novation. This concerns bankruptcy classification, not proof that the agreement is valid.
Keep the debt components distinct
Assume RUB 800,000 principal, RUB 40,000 accrued interest and RUB 10,000 penalty. The arithmetic total before reviewing the terms is 800,000 + 40,000 + 10,000 = RUB 850,000. This does not show that the entire RUB 850,000 automatically becomes new loan principal or retains old security. Explain each component’s treatment in the agreement and calculation. Civil Code Article 414(2) generally terminates ancillary obligations unless otherwise agreed; specific security requirements need their own check.
Information request before agreeing to novation
“Regarding the proposed agreement dated [date], please provide the original debt basis and origination date; principal, interest and penalty calculation; new subject or basis; termination terms; security records and required consents; and an explanation of claim treatment in bankruptcy case [reference].” This requests information and does not consent to replacing the obligation.
Before signing, also establish the procedure stage and signatory authority. Do not use the new document date to bypass priority or claim the old and replacement debt twice. If already signed, retain the original records and explain the entire chronology to the court.
Checked sources: Civil Code Article 414; Plenum No. 6 paragraph 22; Plenum No. 63 paragraph 13.
Documents
- original contract and performance evidence;
- novation agreement and correspondence;
- debt calculations before and after replacement;
- pledge, surety and other security documents;
- accounting records and reconciliations;
- bankruptcy orders and publications.
FAQ
Is extending maturity a novation?
Not by itself; without a new subject or basis it is normally an amendment.
Does security survive?
Ancillary obligations generally end unless the agreement or law preserves them.
Does a late novation create a current claim?
No, if the original claim was registered: Plenum No. 63 paragraph 13 preserves the original obligation’s origination date for this classification.
Can novation be avoided?
Yes under ordinary or bankruptcy-specific grounds, including creditor harm or preference.
Official sources
- Civil Code Article 414
- Supreme Court Plenum Resolution No. 6
- Bankruptcy Law
- Supreme Commercial Court Plenum Resolution No. 63
Related guides: set-off, security deposits and creditor-register filing.
Need to determine how novation affects a claim?
Initial consultation