A reference to a waiting list does not, by itself, explain a refusal to allocate land. In Thematic Review No. 17/2026, Russia’s Supreme Court examined administrative decisions affecting participants in what Russian legislation calls the special military operation (SVO) and their families. Applicants need to establish the particular legal entitlement, their registration on the list and whether allocation order is actually observed.
The Presidium approved the review on 11 November 2026 by Resolution No. 22A/2026. GARANT reported its findings on 18 November. This is a review of judicial practice, rather than a new free-land law: eligibility continues to depend on the applicable federal and regional provisions.
An auction-free lease and free ownership have different legal bases
Section 1 concerns a veteran refused a lease of a gardening plot. The administration relied on a waiting list but provided no evidence that it maintained one and identified no statutory refusal ground under Article 39.16 of the Land Code. With no other obstacles established, the court held the refusal unlawful. This does not abolish a waiting list where one is prescribed and properly maintained.
Section 2 concerns free allocation under regional legislation. The court found defective registration of eligible applicants and allocation to a person further down the list. The administration was required to correct the register, include the applicant and allocate land in the proper order. A demand for immediate allocation and a challenge to unlawful administrative inaction can therefore have different grounds and outcomes.
The absence of a ready plot cannot justify indefinite inaction
In section 3, the administration had not begun creating a plot for an applicant already included in the register. The relevant regional law allowed no more than six months from registration of the application to form the plot. The court found the inaction unlawful and set a deadline for compliance.
That six-month period cannot automatically be applied in every region. A particular dispute requires the applicable local procedure, the event that starts the time limit and evidence of the steps the authority actually took.
Relevant circumstances for a bereaved family
Section 4 confirms priority access to gardening or vegetable-growing land for a family member unable to work who was dependent on a deceased combat veteran and receives, or is entitled to receive, a survivor’s pension. The case concerned a lease; kinship alone does not replace proof of the other eligibility conditions.
Section 5 examines a refusal to a deceased serviceman’s mother because he had registered at his military unit. The court considered his former residence, the reason for deregistration, his award and the regional eligibility rules. In the circumstances established, service-related registration could not deprive the family of land rights at his former residence. This does not give applicants an unrestricted choice of region.
Checks before applying or challenging a decision
The practical lesson is to assemble a timeline and distinguish a dispute about eligibility from one about implementation:
- Identify the legal basis: an auction-free lease or transfer into ownership without charge. Locate the relevant provision and regional procedure.
- Keep the application, proof of receipt, the decision admitting you to the register and any written refusal. Record the dates.
- Prepare evidence of the qualifying status; family applicants also need evidence of kinship and any additional conditions required by their particular entitlement.
- Request information about your position on the list, its operating rules and the steps taken to create the plot.
- Compare the stated refusal ground with the law. Before court proceedings, separately check jurisdiction, the filing deadline and the appropriate remedy.
The land itself also needs checking. Boundaries, permitted use and restrictions are covered in the guide to land documents and due diligence. That guide concerns transactions and does not replace the special allocation procedure for eligible applicants.
Questions about the review
Does the review give every SVO participant a free plot?
No. It explains existing rules. Applicants must establish the conditions of the particular federal or regional entitlement and follow the prescribed procedure.
Is every reference to a waiting list unlawful?
The refusal and its evidence must be assessed. In section 1, the administration failed to substantiate its list; in section 2, the court required compliance with the prescribed allocation order.
Will a court necessarily order immediate transfer of the land?
No. The outcome depends on the breach and the circumstances. Remedies can include ending inaction, correcting registration, creating a plot and allocating it through the proper procedure.
Documents and news source
- Supreme Court page for Review No. 17/2026.
- Full review hosted by ConsultantPlus, PDF: land issues appear in sections 1–5.
- GARANT report of 18 November 2026.
Checked on 18 November 2026. The cases come from the Supreme Court review and are not presented as the author’s own cases.